Start by preparing your glass - if you're serving it chilled, add ice to a 12-ounce cocktail glass first. For the hot version, ensure your apple cider is warm on the stove. Pour 3 ounces of Fireball whiskey into your prepared glass, then top with 7 ounces of apple cider.
Finish by adding your desired garnishes - red apple slices, cinnamon sticks, star anise, and fresh rosemary sprigs all look beautiful and add extra flavor. Give it a gentle stir and enjoy immediately while the flavors are perfectly balanced.
Notes
Choose a glass larger than 12 ounces if using ice and multiple garnishes to ensure everything fits comfortably without overflowing.
Warm your apple cider gently on the stove rather than microwaving for the best hot version - this prevents any harsh flavors from developing.
Taste before adding garnishes and adjust the Fireball-to-cider ratio based on your preference for spice level.
Make the garnishes ahead of time by slicing the apples and storing them in lemon water to prevent browning.