Graham Cracker Homemade Buckeyes

This post may contain affiliate links, please see the disclosure policy for details.

Homemade Buckeyes get a Christmas twist with creamy peanut butter filling, crunchy graham crackers, and white chocolate coating. These no-bake squares bring sweet peanut butter flavor and festive color to holiday candy trays. Follow the shaping and dipping tips below for neatly filled sandwiches with an even coating.

Two halves of a peanut butter sandwich cookie topped with holiday icing.

Save This for Later

We’ll email it to you so you can come back to it anytime.

Best Homemade Buckeyes Recipe You’ll Ever Make

Homemade buckeyes get a Christmas twist with creamy peanut butter filling, crunchy graham crackers, and white chocolate coating. These no-bake squares bring sweet peanut butter flavor and festive color to holiday candy trays. Follow the shaping and dipping tips below for neatly filled sandwiches with an even coating.

This homemade buckeye candy uses a sandwich shape with the filling completely covered. Red and green drizzle turns each square into a decorated Christmas treat.

For more homemade Christmas candy, try my easy crockpot candy or Cool Whip candy. My homemade nougat is another option for filling out a holiday candy assortment.

Christmas Buckeyes Ingredients

See the recipe card below for the full ingredient list and exact measurements.

Ingredients for Christmas treats labeled with their names.
  • Graham cracker sheets: Break each sheet into two squares to create the sandwich layers.
  • Creamy peanut butter: Regular creamy peanut butter makes a smooth filling that holds its shape.
  • Unsalted butter, softened: Softened butter blends into the peanut butter without making the filling overly loose.
  • Vanilla extract: Adds flavor to the sweet peanut butter center.
  • Salt: Balances the powdered sugar and sweet coating.
  • Powdered sugar: Sweetens and thickens the filling so you can shape it into squares.
  • White chocolate melting wafers or white almond bark: Creates the sweet coating that completely covers each sandwich.
  • Red candy melts: Adds the first layer of Christmas drizzle.
  • Green candy melts: Adds a second color across the white coating.
  • Vegetable shortening, optional: Thins the melted candy for easier drizzling, if needed.
  • Christmas sprinkles: Finish the squares while the colored drizzle is still wet.

Substitutions and Variations

  • White coating options: Use white melting wafers or white almond bark designed for dipping and coating.
  • Different holidays: Change the candy melt colors and sprinkles to match another celebration.
  • Simpler decoration: Use one drizzle color and keep the same white coating underneath.
  • Salted butter: Substitute salted butter and omit the added salt, then taste the filling before assembling.

How to Make Homemade Buckeyes

STEP 1: Line two large baking sheets with parchment paper. Break each graham cracker sheet once along the center perforation to make two squares. You should have 48 graham cracker squares.

A mixing bowl filled with crumbly yellow dough.

STEP 2: Beat the peanut butter and softened butter in a large bowl until completely smooth. Mix in the vanilla extract and salt. Gradually beat in the powdered sugar until a thick filling forms. It should be soft enough to shape but firm enough to stay between the crackers.

Twelve graham crackers topped with squares of cookie dough on a baking sheet.

STEP 3: Divide the filling into 24 equal portions. Roll each portion into a ball, then flatten it into a square slightly smaller than the crackers. Gently shape the edges and corners with your fingers.

Ten graham cracker sandwiches on a parchment-lined baking sheet.

STEP 4: Place a peanut butter square onto each of 24 graham cracker squares. Top each with another cracker square. Press gently until the filling spreads almost to the edges. Avoid pressing hard enough to crack the graham crackers.

STEP 5: Arrange the sandwiches on one prepared baking sheet. Refrigerate for 30 minutes, or until the filling is firm and the sandwiches are well chilled.

Smooth white batter in a clear glass loaf pan on a plaid pot holder.

STEP 6: Place the white melting wafers or chopped almond bark in a deep microwave-safe bowl. Microwave in 20–30 second intervals, stirring thoroughly after each interval. Continue until melted and smooth.

Twelve square cookies coated in white icing on a baking sheet.

Step 7: Lower one chilled sandwich into the melted coating. Use a fork or dipping tool to cover the top, bottom, and all four sides. Lift the sandwich and let excess coating drip into the bowl. Lightly tap the fork against the bowl’s edge, then transfer the sandwich to the second baking sheet. Repeat with remaining sandwiches.

Step 8: Allow the white coating to set completely before adding the colored drizzle.

Two small bowls filled with swirled green and red frosting.

Step 9: Microwave the red candy melts in 20-second intervals, stirring after each interval. If needed, stir in one teaspoon of vegetable shortening for a thinner drizzle. Drizzle diagonally across the coated squares.

Square cookies drizzled with red and green icing and sprinkles.

Step 10: Melt the green candy melts using the same method, adding the remaining shortening only if needed. Drizzle in the opposite direction, then immediately add Christmas sprinkles. Let the decorated squares stand at room temperature for 20–30 minutes, or until completely set.

Tips for Making Buckeyes with Graham Crackers

  • Check the filling: It should feel thick and shapeable, with enough structure to hold its corners.
  • Adjust gradually: Add a little powdered sugar if the filling feels too soft to shape.
  • Fix crumbly filling: Mix in another spoonful of peanut butter if the mixture feels overly dry.
  • Work in batches: Keep some sandwiches refrigerated while dipping the others so the filling stays firm.
  • Shape before assembling: Squaring the filling first helps distribute it evenly without crushing the crackers.
White-dipped graham crackers drizzled with red and green icing and sprinkles.

Common Mistakes to Avoid When Making Homemade Christmas Candy

  • Using small rectangles: Break each sheet into two squares, rather than separating all four rectangular sections.
  • Choosing natural peanut butter: Separated oils can make the filling too soft and less predictable.
  • Melting the butter: Use softened butter so the filling stays thick enough to shape.
  • Overheating the coating: Stir between short microwave intervals to help prevent scorching.
  • Decorating too late: Add sprinkles while the colored drizzle is wet so they stick.

How to Store

  • Storage: Let the coating and drizzle harden completely before packing. Separate layers with parchment paper to protect the decorations.
  • Refrigerator: For best quality, refrigerate in an airtight container and enjoy within one week. The crackers may gradually soften during storage.
  • Freezing: For longer storage, freeze in an airtight container for up to one month. Freezing may change the cracker texture.
  • Thawing: Thaw overnight in the refrigerator with the container closed. Let the sealed container warm slightly before opening to reduce condensation.

Serving Suggestions

Serve these Christmas buckeyes after a holiday meal featuring Christmas chicken. Add slow cooker glazed carrots and garlic mashed potatoes with sour cream to round out dinner.

Square holiday cookies decorated with red and green icing and sprinkles.

Homemade Buckeye Candy FAQs

Are these the same as traditional buckeyes?

These are a graham cracker variation with a buckeye-style peanut butter filling. The filling sits between crackers, and white coating covers the entire sandwich.

Can I make these Christmas buckeyes ahead?

Yes, you can make them the day before serving. Let every coating layer set completely before placing them in an airtight container.

Why is my peanut butter filling too soft?

Natural peanut butter or melted butter can make the filling loose. Mix in a little additional powdered sugar until it holds its shape.

Can I use white chocolate chips instead of melting wafers?

Melting wafers or almond bark are the better choices for this recipe. White chocolate chips may melt thicker and can be harder to spread evenly over the sandwiches.

Why won’t my sprinkles stick?

The drizzle may have set before you added them. Decorate a few squares at a time so the sprinkles land on wet candy.

Other Christmas Treats to Try

Two halves of a graham cracker sandwich cookie with white icing and sprinkles.
No ratings yet

Graham Cracker Homemade Buckeyes


Author: Kim Schob
Course: Desserts
Cuisine: American
Prep Time: 30 minutes
Chill and Set Time: 1 hour
Total Time: 1 hour 30 minutes
24 Buckeyes
These Graham Cracker Homemade Buckeyes feature a thick, creamy peanut butter filling sandwiched between graham cracker squares and coated in white chocolate. Red and green candy drizzle and Christmas sprinkles make them a festive treat for holiday cookie trays, parties, and homemade gifts.

Ingredients 

Instructions

  • Line two large baking sheets with parchment paper. Break each graham cracker sheet in half along the center perforation to make 48 squares.
  • In a large mixing bowl, beat the peanut butter and softened butter with an electric mixer until smooth and creamy. Mix in the vanilla extract and salt.
  • Gradually beat in the powdered sugar until a thick, shapeable filling forms. If the filling is too soft, add a little more powdered sugar. If it is dry or crumbly, mix in another spoonful of peanut butter.
  • Divide the filling into 24 equal portions. Roll each portion into a ball, then flatten and shape it into a square slightly smaller than a graham cracker square.
  • Place a portion of filling on each of 24 graham cracker squares. Top with the remaining squares. Press gently until the filling reaches almost to the edges, taking care not to crack the crackers.
  • Arrange the sandwiches on one prepared baking sheet. Refrigerate for 30 minutes, or until the filling is firm and the sandwiches are well chilled.
  • Place the white chocolate melting wafers or chopped white almond bark in a deep microwave-safe bowl. Microwave in 20–30 second intervals, stirring thoroughly after each interval, until melted and smooth.
  • Lower one chilled sandwich into the melted white chocolate. Use a fork or dipping tool to turn it gently until the top, bottom, and all four sides are completely coated.
  • Lift the sandwich out and let the excess coating drip into the bowl. Lightly tap the fork against the bowl, then transfer the sandwich to the second prepared baking sheet.
  • Repeat with the remaining sandwiches. If the coating thickens, microwave for another 10–15 seconds and stir until smooth. Let the white chocolate coating set completely before decorating.
  • Place the red candy melts in a small microwave-safe bowl. Microwave in 20-second intervals, stirring after each interval, until smooth. Stir in 1 teaspoon vegetable shortening if needed for a drizzle consistency.
  • Melt the green candy melts in a separate bowl using the same method. Stir in the remaining 1 teaspoon vegetable shortening if needed.
  • Decorate a few sandwiches at a time. Drizzle red candy diagonally across the tops, then drizzle green candy in the opposite direction. Immediately add Christmas sprinkles while the drizzle is still wet.
  • Let stand at room temperature for 20–30 minutes, or until the candy drizzle is completely set.

Video

Notes

  • Sort crackers first: Set aside cracked pieces before mixing so you have 48 intact squares ready.
  • Use a scale: Weigh the finished filling and divide by 24 for evenly sized portions.
  • Keep utensils dry: Water droplets can cause melted coating to seize, so dry bowls and tools thoroughly.
  • Plan the drizzle: Place a small spoon in each color bowl before decorating to keep the colors separate.

Nutrition Information

Serving: 1Buckeye Calories: 583kcal (29%) Carbohydrates: 70g (23%) Protein: 5g (10%) Fat: 31g (48%) Saturated Fat: 21g (131%) Polyunsaturated Fat: 2g Monounsaturated Fat: 6g Trans Fat: 0.2g Cholesterol: 10mg (3%) Sodium: 206mg (9%) Potassium: 117mg (3%) Fiber: 1g (4%) Sugar: 60g (67%) Vitamin A: 118IU (2%) Vitamin D: 0.1µg (1%) Calcium: 20mg (2%) Iron: 1mg (6%)

Hungry for more?

Follow me on Pinterest and make sure to comment below!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.