Home » Recipes » Basics » Apple Substitute Guide: What To Use When You’re Out Of Apples

Apple Substitute Guide: What To Use When You’re Out Of Apples

This post may contain affiliate links, please see the disclosure policy for details.

Finding yourself needing an apple substitute can happen for various reasons – perhaps you’re dealing with allergies, managing a restricted diet, or simply running out of apples mid-recipe. 

A collage of apple desserts: pies, muffins, apple butter, and more.

Want To Save This Recipe?

Enter your information below, and I’ll send it straight to your inbox! Plus, you’ll get complimentary gifts!

Save Recipe

By submitting this form, you consent to receive emails from Kim Schob.

Whether you’re baking a Double-Crusted Apple Pie Recipe or preparing a fall dessert, understanding how to substitute apples effectively can help you maintain the desired flavors and textures in your cooking and baking endeavors.

Fresh Apple Substitutes By Variety

Red apples in a wooden bowl on a cloth, surrounded by more apples.

Bramley Apple Substitutes

Bramley apples, beloved in British cooking, are prized for their high acidity and ability to break down into a fluffy texture when cooked. 

Rhubarb makes an excellent substitute, offering similar tartness and cooking properties. When using rhubarb, reduce any added sugar in your recipe by about 25% to account for its higher acidity. 

Quince is another remarkable alternative, though it requires longer cooking times to achieve the desired softness. When cooked, quince develops a beautiful rose-gold color and complex flavor that works wonderfully in pies and Apple Oatmeal Bars.

Granny Smith Substitutes

Granny Smith apples are known for their bright, tart flavor and firm texture that holds up well in baking. 

Underripe pears can provide a similar crisp texture and tartness, particularly when used in recipes like Fireball Apple Bread Pudding. Jicama offers comparable crunchiness and a mild, sweet flavor for fresh eating or salads. 

Green pawpaw can be an unexpected but effective substitute. It maintains its structure while cooking and offers a similar tart profile.

Gala/Fuji Substitutes

These sweeter apple varieties are often used for fresh eating and in recipes like Caramel Apple Dump Cake

Asian pears make an ideal substitute, offering similar sweetness and a satisfying crunch. 

Sweet plums can work well in baking applications, though you’ll want to reduce any added liquids in your recipe by about two tablespoons per cup of fruit, as plums tend to release more juice during cooking.

Common Apple Product Substitutes

A jar of apple jelly with a spoon beside it and three yellow apples on a wooden table.

Applesauce Substitutes

Applesauce serves multiple purposes in recipes, acting as both a binding agent and a source of moisture. 

Mashed banana provides similar moisture and binding properties, though it will add a distinct banana flavor to your final product. For a more neutral option, pear sauce works nearly identically to applesauce. 

When used in baking recipes like Gluten Free Apple Cinnamon Streusel Muffins, puréed prunes offer excellent moisture retention and can even enhance chocolate flavors in desserts.

Key substitution ratios:

  • 1 cup applesauce = 1 cup mashed banana
  • 1 cup applesauce = ¾ cup puréed prunes + ¼ cup water

Apple Cider Vinegar Substitutes

Apple cider vinegar’s unique flavor profile combines acidity with subtle fruit notes. White wine vinegar makes the closest substitute, offering similar acidity levels and subtle flavor complexity. 

Rice vinegar can work well in Asian-inspired dishes, while lemon juice provides the necessary acidity but lacks the fermented complexity. 

For Apple Cider Vinegar recipes, you could try replacing it with one tablespoon of white wine vinegar or rice vinegar or 1½ teaspoons of lemon juice mixed with ½ teaspoon water for each tablespoon needed.

Apple Juice Substitutes

When replacing apple juice in recipes, white grape juice offers the closest flavor profile and similar sweetness levels. 

Pear juice provides comparable texture and sweetness, though with a slightly different flavor note. For cooking purposes, you can create a substitute by combining equal parts water and white grape juice concentrate, which provides the necessary sweetness and fruit flavor while maintaining the right liquid ratio in your recipe.

Apple Pie Spice Substitutes

While you can easily make your own Homemade Apple Pie Spice, several alternative spice blend combinations can work beautifully in apple recipes. 

A basic pumpkin pie spice makes an excellent substitute, or you can create your own signature blend using warm spices. Consider these alternative spice combinations:

Apple Jelly Substitutes

Apple jelly’s mild, sweet profile makes it versatile in both sweet and savory applications. Quince jelly makes an excellent substitute, offering similar clarity and a complementary flavor profile. 

Pear jelly provides a nearly identical consistency with a subtle flavor difference. White grape jelly offers similar sweetness and spreading properties for recipes where color isn’t crucial.

Conclusion

Successfully substituting apples or apple products requires understanding their role in your recipe. A suitable alternative is always available whether they provide structure, moisture, acidity, or sweetness. 

While some substitutions may slightly alter your dish’s final taste or texture, they often open up new possibilities for creativity in the kitchen. Don’t be afraid to experiment with different combinations until you find the perfect substitute for your needs.

Subscribe + Follow For More!

To ensure you’re not missing a thing, subscribe to my newsletter.

Follow me on social media below for the latest updates, recipes, and content.

Rate + Review

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like...